What Revoked Home Office Approval for 154 Motorway Speed Cameras Means for Every Driver

Hunton Bridge, UK - February 23, 2020: Evening traffic on busiest British motorway M25 — Photo by JarekKilian
Hunton Bridge, UK - February 23, 2020: Evening traffic on busiest British motorway M25 — Photo by JarekKilian
Hunton Bridge, UK - February 23, 2020: Evening traffic on busiest British motorway M25 — Photo by JarekKilian
Hunton Bridge, UK - February 23, 2020: Evening traffic on busiest British motorway M25 — Photo by JarekKilian
  • The Home Office is revoking the legal approval of the speed camera system on 154 cameras along motorways and A roads, and National Highways is ending its enforcement contract with supplier Verra Mobility.
  • A variable limit fault caused 2,650 erroneous camera activations between 2021 and 2025 across 22 police force areas, fewer than 0.1 percent of all activations on those cameras.
  • Everyone identified and contacted has been offered redress, and traffic officer patrols, CCTV and ANPR cameras now cover the affected sites.

A 17.33 Second Delay Turned Some Limit Changes Into Wrongful Tickets

Ministers announced on 17 November 2026 that the HADECS3X camera system, which enforces variable limits on 154 cameras, loses its Home Office type approval. Roads minister Justin Madders set that out in a written statement to Parliament. Type approval is the status that makes it easier to put camera data before certain legal proceedings as evidence of fact. The Home Office judged that the faults could not be fixed to its satisfaction in any reasonable timeframe. National Highways bought the system on the basis that it kept that approval. It is now ending its enforcement contract with Verra Mobility and is assessing further commercial and legal options.

The fault itself came from a safety feature. HADECS3X waits about 17.33 seconds before accepting that the limit shown on a gantry has changed, so brief or unreliable signal changes do not trigger it. Tracy Westall OBE led an independent review, published the same day, and it traced the fault to the moment when the Motorway Incident Detection and Automatic Signalling system (MIDAS) changed a limit and changed it back inside that window: the camera never registered the change. It carried on enforcing the earlier, lower limit while the gantry showed the higher one. At 50mph, a driver covers about a quarter of a mile in 17.33 seconds, so a gantry that flipped quickly could catch a driver who had done nothing wrong.

The case that exposed it came from a driver on the M5. Avon and Somerset Constabulary raised the alarm with National Highways on 25 January 2025 after a driver contested a Notice of Intended Prosecution. Dashcam footage put a 50mph limit on the gantry, while the notice claimed the driver broke a 40mph limit. Without that footage the fault could have stayed hidden, the review says.

The scale is counted in activations, not fines. The review counts 2,650 erroneous camera activations between 2021 and 2025, which it puts at less than 0.1 percent of all activations in the period. The 16 December 2025 statement to Parliament gave the other half of the sum: about 6 million activations in total on the affected cameras, which makes 2,650 about 0.04 percent. That statement also said not all of the erroneous activations led to enforcement action, so the number of drivers actually hit is smaller still. The DfT puts the share of all roads with affected cameras at around 0.2 percent.

Ten Missed Chances Between a Dashcam Clip and a Public Warning

The review is written in terms of missed opportunities, and it numbers ten. The first came before 2025. The camera was built with a time buffer, and the review says that design meant the situation behind the fault should reasonably have been anticipated and tested. Its lead reviewer wrote: “Many of the subsequent problems arose because this did not happen.”

The second to fourth came in the early stage after the M5 query. A National Highways regional operations centre spotted rapid limit changes and passed that back to the police, but nothing triggered a wider check. An early theory blamed a single faulty MIDAS loop. The review calls that theory “not based on any demonstrable data analysis or other hard evidence”. Police nationally were not told either.

In early March 2025, Road Safety Support, a not-for-profit technical firm working for Avon and Somerset Police, contacted National Highways. By mid-March the emails between them suggested the problem was not isolated and should go to the police and to National Highways legal services. It did not, and the exchanges that named HADECS3X speed determination as a possible cause became the fifth missed opportunity. A technical assessment in mid-March stayed fixed on the MIDAS theory, the sixth.

The first record of the executive team hearing of the problem is a weekly round-up on 9 June 2025, which described a limited MIDAS issue. The review counts that as the seventh missed chance. July brought two more warnings: a challenge to a notice on the M1 that Thames Valley Police took up with the camera suppliers, and a freedom of information request on M62 limit changes. In early August, National Highways legal services raised concerns at director level and were not acted on immediately, the eighth.

A formal investigation team formed on 8 August 2025 and the first executive discussion followed on 11 August. National Highways did not use its Crisis Management Manual, the ninth. The review puts the gap at 10 weeks from the executive’s first notice in early June to a crisis style team. The board, DfT and the Office for Road and Rail were told on 10 September. Over the weeks that followed, the team analysed 2.5m lines of data on limit changes and camera activations, and testing at the Moreton-in-Marsh facility confirmed a discrepancy between the two systems. A briefing on 10 October named all 154 cameras. On 17 October the executive wrote to the National Police Chiefs’ Council and told the camera supplier to stop sending variable speed data to police forces. The review calls the handling of the police relationship around that point the tenth missed opportunity. On 3 November 2025 National Highways notified the 22 police forces, and the public heard in the 16 December statement.

The review found no evidence of a deliberate attempt to withhold information and says its purpose is to identify lessons, not to apportion blame. Its recommendations cover seven themes, from data and technology and crisis handling to legal advice, governance, and procurement and contracting.

What Losing Type Approval Ends and What Still Catches Speeders

The review describes Home Office Type Approval as the process that assesses and approves enforcement devices, so that a record from an approved device can go to court as evidence without further corroboration. Losing it removes that legal shortcut for these cameras. National Highways has said the supplier was scheduled for replacement as operator in 2028 and that date is now brought forward. The review notes that planning for a replacement for HADECS3X was already under way.

The 17 November statement says testing by National Highways and the Home Office found a potential further issue with how the cameras activate in specific circumstances, from the same 2019 upgrade. National Highways’ modelling puts the probability of those circumstances at no more than 0.1 percent, and the statement says there is no real-world evidence it has affected enforcement. Ms Westall reconsidered her recommendations in light of it and found them valid and unchanged.

Enforcement on the same roads carries on by other means. National Highways has put in place further traffic officer service patrols, uses existing CCTV cameras to watch the affected sites, and keeps its existing safety measures, including stopped vehicle detection radar on sections of smart motorway and existing ANPR cameras that identify offenders. Variable limit signs stay in use. Mr Madders said: “Drivers will see no difference in the way they use roads. Safety remains our overriding priority and the additional steps we are taking to implement enforcement arrangements will ensure action can be taken against anyone who breaks the law.” He added: “In short: if you break the law you should expect to be subject to enforcement action.”

Edmund King, AA president, said: “This was not simply a technical fault, but a failure to respond with the urgency motorists deserved.” He added: “Drivers must have confidence that motorway technology is accurate, reliable and properly tested, particularly on so-called ‘smart’ motorways.” His third point: “This is about protecting lives and restoring public confidence.”

Greg Smith, Conservative shadow transport minister, said: “This is beyond unacceptable.” He went on: “To sit on a report detailing highways failings is testament to how little this government cares about motorists, their safety and their journeys. They are playing fast and loose with safety.” The review is dated July 2026 and was published on 17 November. Richard Holden, Conservative shadow transport secretary, said: “Thousands of drivers have been hit with fines when they have done nothing wrong, with Labour ministers asleep at the wheel throughout.” He continued: “When errors were found they should have been dealt with immediately. It should not have taken so many warnings to get action nor have taken so long to resolve.” And: “We all know Labour is in an ideological war against drivers but presiding over the missing of ten points [in time] during which opportunities for action were missed is unbelievable.”

What a Driver Fined Between 2021 and 2025 Can Do Now

The government promise on money and points predates the review. In its 16 December 2025 statement it said anyone wrongly fined would be refunded and any points incorrectly applied would be removed, and that the police would prioritise the most serious cases. The statement also said tens of thousands of speed awareness courses were cancelled, and thousands of old fixed penalty notices and prosecutions dropped, after the National Police Chiefs’ Council told affected forces to cancel wider prosecutions in progress. Our report on the earlier refund promise has the detail.

Drivers who took a course can read the speed awareness course rules for what those involve. The 17 November statement says the government has offered redress to everyone it has identified and contacted, and will keep providing it to eligible people it identifies later. The Department for Transport guidance published on 15 December 2025 tells drivers who think they were affected to wait for their police force to contact them and says they do not have to take any action at this stage. National Highways gave the police the data to make that contact. Neither statement, and not the review, offers a form, a helpline or a deadline for starting a claim.

What happens next sits with the DfT. Any driver unsure what an endorsement means for a licence can read how penalty points work. The statement says the department will monitor National Highways’ progress on the review’s recommendations and hold it to account through its sponsorship arrangements, and that the government has accepted all of them. National Highways has said it has already begun to implement the improvements. His predecessor Simon Lightwood also instructed National Highways in the December 2025 statement to keep investigating back to 2019, when the camera upgrade began, so more drivers could still be identified.

Want more car content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for the best automotive news and analysis on the internet.

If you enjoyed this article, be sure to follow us on Microsoft Start.

Sources

Reviewed by Preetam Gadekar

Avatar photo

George Howson

George Howson is an FIA accredited Formula 1 journalist with his finger on the pulse of UK motoring regulations. He writes about the rules, fines and changes that affect UK drivers, and he makes videos to go with Motoring Chronicle’s stories. An engineer by background, a father and a keen traveller, he is a motoring nut who is never afraid to ask the questions most would back out of, and he always tells it like it is.

Leave a Comment

More in News

Blue colored sign PRIVATE PARKING at the entrance of car park

How Drivers Who Moved House Can Challenge a Parking CCJ for £321

A reader's case in This is Money shows how an ...
Businesses invited to take part in trial of the next-generation vehicle to grid EV charging

Cupra Born Recall Hits 486 EVs, With an 80% Charge Limit Until Fixed

Volkswagen Group Australia has recalled 486 Cupra Born EVs from ...
Khaki double-cab ute driving along a country road past pine trees

Diesel Costs 47.2 Cents More Than Petrol in Five Cities, 39.1 in Regions

Diesel averaged 266.4 cents a litre across Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, ...
Cleaning engine injectors

Turbo Failure Symptoms Have Other Suspects First, Say Two Turbo Makers

Loss of power, smoke and noise are the three symptoms ...
2026 Honda Passport TrailSport

NHTSA Opens Probe of 701 Complaints on Honda and Acura Start-Stop Failures

NHTSA opened the engineering-stage investigation EA26007 on Nov. 13 over ...

Trending on Motoring Chronicle

Lamborghini Veneno (image courtesy Lamborghini)

Is The Lamborghini Veneno Street Legal?

Yes, the Lamborghini Veneno is street legal. Every unit produced ...
An automatic number plate recognition camera and a decoy surveillance camera on a pole

Why Fake Number Plates Could Leave Any UK Driver With Someone Else’s Fine

A trial camera system on three stretches of road detected ...

Why Hagerty’s Index Shows Classic Car Values at Their Lowest Since 2018

Hagerty UK's Best of British index, the benchmark for how ...
A mechanic is opening the cap of the power steering fluid to check the hydraulic fluid level

What the Scrapped Four Year MOT Plan Means for Every Car Owner

If you were hoping to skip a year of MOT ...
FP200078-Edit

Audi Concept C lights up London

The Audi Concept C, an unambiguous preview of the brand’s ...