Turbo Failure Symptoms Have Other Suspects First, Say Two Turbo Makers
Loss of power, smoke and noise are the three symptoms owners pin on a failing turbocharger, and the makers’ workshop guides send mechanics to the air filter, hoses, injectors, exhaust and oil before the turbo itself. Garrett Motion and Holset both say to identify the cause before replacing the unit. On Holset’s lists for power loss and smoke, the turbocharger comes last.
Key takeaways:
- Garrett and Holset both tell workshops to check other systems before condemning a turbo, and Holset’s lists for power loss and smoke end with the turbo.
- Noise that persists after the joints are checked, and a rotor that is tight or loose, are the symptoms the makers keep with the turbo, and for the rotor Holset points to oil.
- Garrett says more than 90 per cent of turbo failures are oil related, a figure from the maker with no dataset behind it on its page.
The Symptoms Every List Gives and the Suspects the Makers Put First
Loss of Power: The Turbo Is the Last of Seven Suspects
Garrett Motion, a major turbocharger maker, publishes a diagnostics guide for workshops that opens a lack of power with three checks. Filter, hoses and pipes must be clean and in good condition. The fuel injection system must be in good condition and correctly adjusted. The exhaust system, including the catalytic converter and DPF, must not be blocked or damaged.
Holset, the Cummins turbocharger business, prints a longer failure diagnosis poster for engines that lack power. It names seven causes: a dirty air filter, an air intake restriction, a cracked mounting flange or missing gasket, an exhaust restriction from a foreign object, fuel pump, injectors or valve timing set incorrectly, burnt valves or pistons, and in seventh place a damaged turbocharger.
The lists follow what an engine needs. Garrett calls a turbocharger an air pump, so a restriction on the way in or out costs power. A dirty air filter heads Holset’s list for power loss and smoke, and a clogged one shows as a lack of power when accelerating. A diesel particulate filter clogging with soot also costs power, and not every car has one.
Limp mode gives the same flat throttle, and a faulty boost sensor can trigger limp mode with the turbo undamaged. Both makers publish lists, not failure rates, and Holset does not say its order ranks the causes. Garrett sums up the instruction: “If you think your vehicle might have a turbo-related problem, stop before you replace because turbo damage can often be a symptom of an underlying problem rather than the cause itself.”
Smoke and Oil Use Come With Six Checks Before the Turbo
For excessive smoke or oil consumption Garrett lists six checks: air filters not restricted, oil to the car maker’s specification, a clean oil drain pipe, normal crankcase pressure with a working breather, sound hoses and joints, and a search for lubrication problems in the engine block if oil or carbon deposits appear on the exhaust manifolds or in the turbine.
Holset’s smoke column carries six causes of its own: a dirty air filter, an air intake restriction, a cracked mounting flange or missing gasket, fuel pump, injectors or valve timing set incorrectly, a wastegate mechanism set incorrectly, and last a damaged turbocharger. Neither maker starts with the turbo.
A worn turbo can still smoke. Garrett says fine carbon in the oil, once its concentration becomes too high, acts as an abrasive on the bearing and shaft, usually with a sharp rise in noise and oil leaking past the turbine end seal and burning. On vehicles without a particulate filter the smoke is noticeable. Smoke has many sources and each colour points to a different fault.
The Symptoms the Makers Keep With the Turbo
A Whine or Whistle Starts With the Joints Before the Bearings
Holset’s poster gives a noisy or whistling turbocharger its own column: “Often the noise comes from air/gas leakage due to pre-turbine exhaust gas or air/boost leaks. Check all joints. If noise continues, check turbocharger clearances and wheels for housing contact.” Garrett’s noise checks start the same way, with loose or damaged pipework and brackets, then leaks or cracks in the intercooler.
Leaks come first, and persistent noise is then the symptom Holset treats most seriously. Holset warns: “Never continue to operate an engine with a suspect or noisy turbocharger as this could result in total engine failure.” Garrett links a sharp rise in noise to a bearing worn by contaminated oil. A new noise that keeps rising is a garage question the same day.
Neither maker offers an owner a roadside test, and none is offered here. The useful question to put to a garage is what it checked before naming the turbo. The expected answer: joints, pipework and intercooler, then clearances and wheels.
A Rotor That Seizes or Runs Loose Points at the Oil
Holset traces a rotor that is tight or seized to the lubricating oil. Degraded oil can build up carbon inside the bearing housing and restrict rotation, an insufficient or intermittent drop in oil pressure can seize the rotor, and so can dirt in the oil. Each cause sits upstream of the turbo, in the oil supply or in what the oil carries to the bearings.
A rotor with too much play follows the same logic. Holset says each turbocharger has specific axial and radial clearances, that these are sometimes mis-diagnosed as worn bearings, and that clearances out of specification could trace to too little oil, dirt ingress or coolant in the oil. Overspeed is a separate fault: Garrett’s specialist stage names an orange peel texture on the back of the compressor wheel as a clear sign of it, which is a specialist’s finding.
Low oil pressure runs through both columns, and turbocharged engines are more sensitive to it than naturally aspirated ones. Neither maker publishes how often each oil fault occurs, so the lists show where a mechanic looks and give no odds.
What Garrett and Holset Say Kills a Turbo
Garrett Puts Oil Behind More Than 90 Per Cent of Failures
On its page about why turbochargers fail, Garrett says less than 1 per cent of turbos fail from manufacturing defects and that most failures come from three killers: oil starvation, oil contamination and foreign object damage. It says more than 90 per cent of failures are oil related. Both figures are the maker’s own statement, and the page gives no dataset, sample or date.
Garrett’s diagnostics page lists four categories of damage: foreign objects, lack of lubrication, oil contamination, and overspeed with excessive temperature. Starvation and contamination are separate faults. Starvation means too little oil reaches the bearings, usually from blocked or leaking pipes or a turbo fitted without priming, Garrett says. Contamination means dirty oil does reach them.
Holset lists eight points under insufficient oil supply, and three causes are worth asking a garage about: low or no oil in the sump, a broken or restricted oil feed pipe, and a turbocharger refitted without adequate priming. The first is the cheapest to rule out, and what a dipstick reading means takes minutes to learn.
Cold Starts, Hot Shutdowns and a Replacement That Fails Again
Garrett lists driving habits as other reasons for failure. Hard acceleration from cold gives the oil no time to circulate and starves the turbo and engine bearings. Hot engine shutdown can build carbon in the turbo and lead to bearing failure. Holset adds degraded oil carbonising in service and infrequent oil changes, and Garrett names carbon from extended oil change intervals.
Oil and filter go in on the schedule in the car’s handbook. Holset’s poster recommends idling two to three minutes to cool the bearing system before shutting down, which is advice from a turbocharger maker for the engines its poster covers. The handbook for the car is the authority on shutdown, and no idle time is set here.
A replacement raises the stakes. Holset says a new turbocharger goes in with fresh oil and a fresh filter, and its poster ends with a line aimed at this mistake: “Remember, if the root cause of the problem is not identified and corrected, your problem will remain!” Garrett’s advice to stop before replacing makes the same point.
The checks on both makers’ lists cost a filter, a hose clip or an oil change, and the wrong guess costs a turbocharger. A replacement fitted to an engine with a blocked oil feed or a leaking joint inherits the fault that killed the last one. Garrett and Holset both put the root cause ahead of the part.
Want more car content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for the best automotive news and analysis on the internet.
If you enjoyed this article, be sure to follow us on Microsoft Start.
Reviewed by Preetam Gadekar