Every Driver Faces Car Insurance Prices 7.4 Percent Higher Than Last Year, ONS Shows

Road traffic, London, England, UK
Road traffic, London, England, UK (image courtesy Deposit Photos)
Road traffic, London, England, UK
Road traffic, London, England, UK (image courtesy Deposit Photos)
  • Motor vehicle insurance prices ran 7.4 percent above their October 2025 level in the ONS series, up from 6.8 percent in September and more than double the 3.6 percent rise in consumer prices overall.
  • The Association of British Insurers puts the average premium actually paid in the third quarter at £562, only 2 percent up on a year earlier, while the ONS follows prices for similar cover month to month, which is closer to what a renewing driver meets.
  • The next ONS figures land on 16 December, and the price on the renewal notice is the number to test against fresh quotes for identical cover before then.

What 7.4 Percent Does to Your Renewal Letter

The renewal letter now carries a bigger number than it did a year ago. The Office for National Statistics put motor vehicle insurance prices 7.4 percent above their October 2025 level, a step up from 6.8 percent in September and more than double the 3.6 percent rise in consumer prices overall. July 2026 read higher at 8.4 percent, while 7.4 percent tops every month from July 2024 to June 2026.

A second ONS figure is in circulation, and it reads 8.0 percent. That is the wider transport insurance series, which holds travel insurance alongside car cover. The ONS travel insurance index stood at 167.2 in September and 196.7 in October, a jump of about 18 percent in a month, and that jump lifts the wider series above the motor one. For a driver renewing a car policy, the figure to use is 7.4 percent.

Take the average premium the Association of British Insurers recorded for the third quarter of 2026, £562. A rise of 7.4 percent adds £42 and takes the bill to £604. Treat that as arithmetic on an average. Your own renewal price set against last year’s is the figure that counts.

From a 14.9 Percent Fall to a 7.4 Percent Rise

The ONS data shows how fast the market has turned. The annual rate for motor vehicle insurance stood at 43.8 percent in December 2023, then fell through 2024 and into early 2025 until it reached minus 14.9 percent in March 2025. That means prices in March 2025 sat 14.9 percent below March 2024. From that low to October 2026 the annual rate has swung by 22.3 percentage points.

The recovery began in the autumn of 2025. The annual rate was minus 4.9 percent in September 2025, minus 2.0 in October and minus 1.4 in November, then turned positive in December at 0.8. It reached 4.1 in January 2026, dipped to 3.1 in February, then climbed through 4.4 in March, 5.4 in April, 5.7 in May and 6.4 in June to 8.4 in July. August fell back to 4.3 percent, September came in at 6.8 and October at 7.4. That is 11 months running above zero.

Month to month, the ONS recorded a rise of 0.2 percent in October against a fall of 0.4 percent in October 2025. September carried the bigger move, a monthly rise of 3.2 percent. The August dip has a plain explanation in the monthly rates: prices fell 1.3 percent in August 2026 after rising 2.6 percent in August 2025, so the yearly comparison shrank.

The ONS published the series on 18 November. Defaqto’s index of competitive premiums found motor premiums 2.7 percent higher at the end of September than a year earlier, the first annual rise after 2023, and the earlier report on why insurance bills rose 2.7 percent covers that turn.

Why the Price You Paid and the ONS Figure Differ

Three bodies give three different numbers, and each is right about what it measures.

The ABI averages what customers paid across millions of policies. Its third quarter figure of £562 was £4 lower than the second quarter and £11, or 2 percent, higher than a year earlier. Adjusted for inflation, it is £7 lower than in the third quarter of 2025. Drivers who shopped around, switched to cheaper cover or accepted a higher excess pull that average down. The ONS works differently, following the cost of similar cover over time, so its rate leans toward what a renewing customer meets if the policy stays the same.

Confused.com and the consultancy WTW publish a third measure from quotes. Their Car Insurance Price Index, released on 23 September, put the average cost of annual cover at £713. That sits £282 below the £995 recorded in December 2023. Premiums for the widest level of cover fell 0.8 percent over the three months before the index came out, after rising in February (0.4 percent), April (2.3 percent), May (0.3 percent) and June (1.9 percent). On £713, a 7.4 percent rise would add £53 and take the bill to £766.

Location changes the bill sharply. The index put inner London at about £1,079 a policy, Northern Ireland at £1,059 and outer London at £888, against £474 in Llandrindod in Wales. Pricing is also diverging by age and insurer, so a national figure says little about what one household will be quoted, and the way quotes vary by region is worth reading before a renewal arrives.

Tim Rourke, EMEA P&C leader for insurance consulting and technology at WTW, said: “Drivers have benefited from a more stable pricing environment in 2026, but the underlying cost of settling motor claims remains under pressure.”

He added: “Increasing repair complexity, rising repair costs and ongoing inflation uncertainty continue to create challenges for insurers to navigate.”

What Is Pushing Prices Up

The pressure shows in claims. Motor insurers paid out £3.2bn in the third quarter of 2026, the same as the second quarter’s record and 8 percent more than a year earlier, the ABI’s tracker shows. The average claim was £4,900, up 1 percent year on year. A windscreen claim averaged £298, up 5 percent on the second quarter and 9 percent on the year.

Chris Bose, director of general insurance and international policy at the ABI, said: “With more than £3bn paid out last quarter, matching the previous quarter’s record, insurers continue to play a vital role in helping drivers, passengers and road users recover when things go wrong.”

He also said: “While competitive premiums are welcome news for customers, persistently high claims costs are putting significant pressure on insurers.”

Bose continued: “Bringing these costs down is a key aim of the government’s motor insurance taskforce and is crucial to ensuring a sustainable and competitive market for consumers in the long-term. We’ll work with government, insurers and the wider sector as the taskforce’s recommendations are implemented and this collaborative approach remains essential.”

Repair costs are climbing too. ONS data show vehicle maintenance and repair prices up 5.2 percent in the year to October, from 3.7 percent in September. Spare parts and accessories eased to 2.8 percent from 5.1 percent. EY forecasts that the private motor market will pay out about £1.08 in claims and costs for every £1 of premium in 2026.

What to Do Before the Renewal Date

Steve Dukes, chief executive at Confused.com, described what happens when a renewal price climbs: “Car insurance prices are more stable now than they have been in recent years. At the same time, we know many customers are also seeing their renewal price increase, which can lead to more customers shopping around.”

He went on: “And this is a clear opportunity for insurers to be competitive when it comes to new business pricing. Insurers that are using data and customer insight to create genuine choice and value for consumers will grow in this market.”

First, pull last year’s premium from the policy documents and set it beside the new renewal price. The difference is your own rate of increase, and it can sit far above or below the 7.4 percent national figure.

Second, price the same cover elsewhere. Match the cover level, the excess, the annual mileage and the named drivers line for line, as a cheaper quote that drops a feature or raises the excess is a different product. Get quotes from at least two comparison sites and from one insurer that sells only direct.

Third, check the no claims discount status and the details on the quote against your own records, then act inside the renewal window. Timing counts too, and buying car insurance early is covered in an earlier story on what the purchase date does to quotes.

What Happens Next

The next ONS inflation figures are due on 16 December 2026, which will show whether the motor insurance rate holds near 7.4 percent in November. The Bank of England makes its final rate decision of the year on 17 December. It raised Bank Rate to 4 percent on 5 November, its first increase after 2023, by an 8 to 1 vote, and expects inflation to reach about 5 percent by the middle of next year.

EY has pencilled in premium rises of 4 percent this year and 12 percent in 2027. Multiplied together, the two forecasts compound to about 16.5 percent. That is arithmetic on a forecast, and the ABI and ONS releases will show whether it holds.

Until then the number to act on is the one on the renewal notice. The ONS puts the price of car cover 7.4 percent above last October, and the notice shows how much of that has landed on your policy.

Want more car content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for the best automotive news and analysis on the internet.

If you enjoyed this article, be sure to follow us on Microsoft Start.

Sources

Reviewed by Preetam Gadekar

Avatar photo

George Howson

George Howson is an FIA accredited Formula 1 journalist with his finger on the pulse of UK motoring regulations. He writes about the rules, fines and changes that affect UK drivers, and he makes videos to go with Motoring Chronicle’s stories. An engineer by background, a father and a keen traveller, he is a motoring nut who is never afraid to ask the questions most would back out of, and he always tells it like it is.

Leave a Comment

More in News

Red compact sedan driving along a city street

2027 Honda Civic Sport-L Starts at $28,495 With Leather and Heated Seats

The 2027 Honda Civic Sport-L is starting to reach dealers ...
Silver electrified sedan seen from the front against a concrete wall

Redesigned 2027 Hyundai Elantra Is 3.4 Inches Longer, Hybrid Targets 53 MPG

The all-new 2027 Hyundai Elantra and 2028 Elantra Hybrid debuted ...

Every Driver Over 70 Self-Certifies Eyesight as DfT Logs 581 Casualties Involving Poor Driver Sight

The Department for Transport's final 2025 table records 424 collisions ...
Copper electric SUV with light bar headlights parked at dusk with hills behind

Skoda Peaq Scores 94 Percent for Crash Protection in Five-Star Euro NCAP Test

Skoda's electric Peaq has earned five Euro NCAP stars, and ...
Diesel being pumped into car at petrol station

Diesel Hits a Record 199.5p and a Fill Costs £29 More Than 2025

Diesel averaged a record 199.5p a litre in October and ...

Trending on Motoring Chronicle

Parking ticket under wind screen wiper of a car

Why Fake QR Code Parking Scams Have Soared 1,300 Per Cent in Three Years

The number of fake QR code stickers appearing on parking ...

Rivian Recalls 3,829 More EVs After Turn Signals Fail Again

Rivian is recalling 3,829 more R1S and R1T electric vehicles ...
Car on coins and calculator Car loan, Finance, saving money, insurance and leasing time concept.

Interest on a Used Car Loan Has Nearly Doubled From 2019 Levels, Data Shows

The average driver financing a used car now pays close ...
Diesel being pumped into car at petrol station

Diesel Hits $8.50 a Gallon in California as Truckers Warn Grocery Prices Will Follow

AAA's state-by-state data shows diesel averaging $8.50 a gallon in ...
2027 Genesis GV60 Magma

Genesis GV60 Magma Priced From $69,950 With Up to 641 Horsepower

Genesis has priced its first high-performance model at $69,950 before ...