The Oldest Classic Car Owners Are the Keenest to Bring Back the MOT
The classic car owners most in favour of bringing annual testing back for historic vehicles are the oldest ones. In a survey of more than 1,200 drivers by classic car insurer Hagerty UK, 69 per cent of owners over 71 said they would welcome an MOT designed for classics, against 53 per cent of those under 51. Younger owners were far more likely to defend the current exemption.
Key takeaways:
- 69 per cent of classic owners over 71 want a classic-specific MOT, against 53 per cent of those under 51.
- 40 per cent of over-71s have avoided, or would avoid, driving a classic on roads such as motorways over roadworthiness concerns, against 25 per cent of under-51s.
- 70 per cent of under-51s say the MOT exemption is a good thing, against 56 per cent of over-71s.
The Rule Classic Owners Are Debating
Under the current rules, a vehicle becomes eligible for historic status once it reaches 40 years old, provided it has had no substantial changes in the last 30 years. Historic vehicles do not need an annual MOT. The cut-off rolls forward each year, so a steady stream of cars from the 1980s now joins the exempt list every spring.
That means cars well within living memory as everyday transport can be driven without any annual check. As Hagerty points out, many popular models now fall into the exempt group, and no tester looks at them unless the owner chooses to book one.
Many owners do exactly that. In Hagerty’s survey, 90 per cent of respondents own a classic car, and 43 per cent said they still put their cars through an MOT each year, even though the law does not require it.
Support Rises With Every Age Band
Across the whole sample, 64 per cent of respondents said they would welcome a classic-specific version of the MOT. The breakdown by age shows that support climbing steadily with each group.
- Owners under 51: 53 per cent in favour
- Owners aged 51 to 70: 63 per cent in favour
- Owners over 71: 69 per cent in favour
Support for the exemption moves in the opposite direction. Seven in ten owners under 51, 70 per cent, said the exemption is a good thing, falling to 56 per cent among the over-71s. Across all respondents, 61 per cent backed the exemption, with most of them saying the standard MOT is not suited to older vehicles.
Those two findings sit together more easily than they first appear. Plenty of owners like the freedom of the exemption, and also accept that a test designed for classics would be an improvement on the current choice between a modern MOT and none at all.
Older Owners Are the Most Cautious on the Road
The age gap shows up in how owners drive. Two in five owners over 71, 40 per cent, said they have avoided, or would avoid, driving a classic on certain roads such as motorways over concerns about roadworthiness. Among owners under 51, the figure was one in four, 25 per cent.
Older owners were also more open to exempt vehicles carrying a visible badge or sticker:
- Owners under 51: 20 per cent in favour
- Owners over 71: 31 per cent in favour
A clear majority in every age band still rejected the idea.
The wider survey found broad unease about what the exemption allows. More than half of respondents, 51 per cent, said they feel the exemption helps drivers use unroadworthy vehicles, and 21 per cent said they had seen unroadworthy vehicles on the road as a result.
What a Lighter Test Could Look Like
Older respondents put forward practical alternatives to a full annual MOT. “Possibly could be MOT checked every two years, bearing in mind mileage on classic cars is lower,” one wrote. Another suggested the point of sale: “Any classic or vintage car should have a current MOT when sold, to ensure the car is safe for the new owner.” A third proposed the clubs take a role: “There could be club involvement in policing members’ cars.”
“Our survey shows many classic vehicle owners have concerns over MOT exemption,” said Mark Roper, managing director of Hagerty UK. “It is clear that many owners would welcome a classic-specific MOT test, one that proves roadworthiness with tests more appropriate for the age of vehicle. Most agree there should be some form of annual inspection, ideally by a classic car expert, particularly as many popular cars are now exempt from any form of annual test and can be driven freely regardless of condition.”
The Historic and Classic Vehicles Alliance supports the exemption, but sees room for change. “We support regular safety and roadworthiness checks for historic vehicles that are exempt from the statutory MOT, particularly when a vehicle is being returned to the road after a period of storage, following restoration or significant mechanical work,” said Dale Keller, its chief executive. “There is a clear rationale for the current exemption, not least because historic vehicles can require specialist knowledge to assess properly. However, we believe there is a strong case for developing an optional, industry-led roadworthiness inspection specifically for MOT-exempt historic vehicles.”
Why Age Makes a Difference to a Test
The MOT data for younger cars shows why a test still has a job to do on older ones. Our analysis of 33 million tests in 2024 found the failure rate climbs steadily with a car’s age, reaching 34.5 per cent on cars aged 16 and over. Suspension, brakes and corrosion account for a growing share of the faults as cars get older.
Classic owners argue, with some justification, that a cherished 45-year-old car is not comparable to a neglected 16-year-old hatchback. Of the respondents who do not put their cars through a regular MOT, 98 per cent said they maintain them to a standard that would pass anyway.
The debate is less about whether classics should be checked, and more about who checks them and against what standard. On Hagerty’s figures, the owners with the longest experience of these cars are the ones most willing to have that conversation.
If you enjoyed this article, be sure to follow us on Microsoft Start.