Suffolk County Drivers Can Claim Up to $36 Back on Red-Light Fees by Dec. 8

GEM Motoring Assist warning about red light runners at UK junctions
Reading, United Kingdom - May 05 2018: A Mini cooper at a red traffic light on Rose Kiln Lane
GEM Motoring Assist warning about red light runners at UK junctions
Reading, United Kingdom - May 05 2018: A Mini cooper at a red traffic light on Rose Kiln Lane
  • Drivers who paid the $30 administrative fee on a Suffolk County, New York red-light camera ticket at any point from April 1, 2013 can claim up to $36 for each fee.
  • Claims must be filed online by 11:59 p.m. Eastern or postmarked by December 8, 2026, and the November 9 deadline to exclude yourself or object has already passed.
  • No money moves until the court gives final approval and any appeals end, and every payment shrinks pro rata if claims top the $45 million pot.

The $30 Add-On a Court Called Illegal Is Now Worth a Claim

If you paid the $30 administrative fee that Suffolk County, New York, attached to a red-light camera ticket, you belong to a class action settlement worth up to $45 million. Each fee you paid is worth up to $36 to you if you file a claim by December 8, 2026.

The case is McGrath v. Suffolk County, Index No. 608155/2016, in the Suffolk County Supreme Court. Robert McGrath, Jr. brought it for every driver who paid the fee. The county and its Traffic and Parking Violation Agency deny any wrongdoing. A court hearing on December 8 decides whether the deal stands.

Nothing arrives in your bank account yet. The claim form is the first step, and it is the only step that puts you in line for money.

Who Qualifies and How Much Each Fee Is Worth

The class covers any person or business that paid the $30 fee to Suffolk County between April 1, 2013 and today for a red-light camera violation. Where you live does not count. A driver from another county or another state who ran a Suffolk camera and paid qualifies the same as a resident.

The payout runs up to $36 for each fee paid, so a driver who paid the fee on three tickets can claim up to $108. The $36 is $6 more than the $30 fee itself.

That figure is a ceiling. The county has agreed to pay up to $45,000,000 to valid claimants and not a dollar more. If the claims add up to more than that, every payment is cut by the same percentage. The county collected roughly $91 million in these fees over a decade, which is just over twice the pot, so a full turnout would trigger a cut. One published estimate puts the final payment near $18 per ticket if every eligible driver files. The notice does not give that number, and the actual figure stays unknown until the claims are counted.

If claims come in under $45 million, the county pays only what was claimed. Unclaimed money stays with the county.

How to File Before December 8

The court-approved notice gives two routes. File online at www.SuffolkRedLightSettlement.com by 11:59 p.m. Eastern Time on December 8, 2026. Or mail a claim form with a postmark on or before that date to McGrath v. Suffolk County, et al., c/o Kroll Settlement Administration LLC, P.O. Box 5324, New York, NY 10150-5324. Questions go to the administrator at (833) 447-6790.

Drivers on the county’s list should have a postcard. The settlement agreement says each postcard carries a unique identification number, the number of fees the county’s own records show you paid and the total you can receive before any pro rata cut. A prepaid return claim form tears off the card, and the same card gives instructions for filing online.

The county supplied names and last known addresses, and the administrator ran them through the National Change of Address database. A returned postcard is re-mailed only when the Postal Service supplies a forwarding address. If you moved and never saw a card, call the administrator on (833) 447-6790 to ask about your fees and to update your address.

Every claimant signs under penalty of perjury, online by electronic confirmation, that they paid the fee within the class period. The administrator checks each claim against the county’s records and screens for duplicate or fraudulent filings. A form with a gap gets a notice and 30 days to fix it before the claim is rejected.

Why Payment Is Not Close

The notice says payments follow final approval, after any challenges to that approval end. The court meets on December 8 at 10:00 a.m. Eastern at 1 Court Street in Riverhead, NY. The hearing decides whether to approve the settlement, the lawyers’ fees and the award to the class representative. The date and time can change without further notice.

Approval alone does not start the clock. The agreement defines the Effective Date as the day the final approval order is entered without material changes and the time to appeal has run out, or any appeal has ended in the order’s favor. The county then has 30 days to put the money with the administrator, and the administrator has 14 more days to pay. The agreement allows electronic transfer, a prepaid debit card or a mailed check, depending on the choice each claimant makes.

Cash the money when it comes. A check is good for 90 days from mailing and a debit card for one year. After that, the funds go back to the county for driver safety programs, and the claimant has no right to them. The agreement also puts any tax consequences on each person who receives a payment.

The county has a motion pending for leave to appeal the class certification to the New York State Court of Appeals. If the court rejects the deal, both sides keep every right and defense they had before it.

What the Courts Decided About the Fee

Section 1111-b of the New York Vehicle and Traffic Law caps what a red-light camera violation can cost at $50, or $75 once a late fee applies. Suffolk County added a $30 administrative fee to that.

On April 27, 2020, the Suffolk County Supreme Court granted McGrath summary judgment, declared anything above $50 (or $75 with a late fee) void as a matter of law and barred the county from collecting it. The county stopped imposing the extra $30 on January 25, 2023. The court certified the class on February 9, 2023. On November 27, 2024, the Appellate Division, Second Judicial Department, affirmed the 2020 order, and on December 11, 2024, it affirmed the class certification. The county ended its red-light camera program in December 2024.

“They are sort of correcting a wrong,” said attorney David Raimondo, one of the three lawyers the court appointed to represent the class.

“It turns out that the fee that was being charged was in excess of what’s called the enabling statute in Suffolk County,” Raimondo said of the legal flaw.

The $45 million is separate from the lawyers’ pay. Class counsel will ask the court for up to $12,500,000 in fees and a $5,000 award for McGrath, and the county pays those amounts on top of the claims pot.

Nassau Drivers, the Release and What to Do Before December 8

This settlement covers Suffolk County only. A similar case, Guthart v. Nassau County, Index No. 604271/2016, is separate. The Second Department ruled on November 27, 2024 that Nassau’s liability above $50 was illegal, and Nassau stopped charging more. On October 6, 2025, the trial court sided with the county once more and dismissed the complaint, and the plaintiff’s appeal is pending. Raimondo says Nassau charged fees of up to $100 that he describes as illegal, and Nassau has not settled.

If you paid a fee in Nassau, no claim form exists today. A Connecticut case shows the same fight elsewhere: Greenwich school zone cameras are back with $50 fines while a suit seeks refunds.

The November 9 date to exclude yourself or object has passed. Staying in the class, which is the default, means you give up the right to sue Suffolk County, its officers and the vendors that collected the fee over the claims this deal resolves, and that holds whether or not you file for money. Doing nothing leaves you with the release and no payment. Anyone who excluded themselves on time kept the right to sue and gets nothing from the deal.

Find your postcard and its identification number, then file online or mail the tear-off form in time for the postmark. If no card arrived, call (833) 447-6790 and ask about your fees. Use only the web address and mailing address printed in the court notice, and keep a copy of what you submit. Red-light and speed camera fines are spreading in other cities, so check any camera ticket you pay against the limit your own state sets. Expect nothing before the court rules and the appeals window closes, and plan to cash a check within 90 days of mailing.

Want more car content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for the best automotive news and analysis on the internet.

If you enjoyed this article, be sure to follow us on Microsoft Start.

Sources

Reviewed by Preetam Gadekar

Jarrod Partridge

Jarrod Partridge is the founder of Motoring Chronicle and an FIA accredited journalist with over 30 years of experience following motorsport and the global automotive industry. A member of the AIPS International Sports Press Association, Jarrod has covered Formula 1 races and automotive events at venues around the world, bringing first-hand insight to every race report, car review, and industry analysis he writes. His work spans the full breadth of motoring — from the latest EV launches and road car reviews to the cutting edge of motorsport competition.

Leave a Comment

More in News

An automatic number plate recognition camera and a decoy surveillance camera on a pole

Hempstead Drivers Can Sue Together for Refunds of $250 Bus Camera Tickets

A Nassau County judge ruled Nov. 10 that three groups ...
Yellow Acura Integra Type S driving beside a yellow first-generation Integra on a hill road

2027 Acura Integra Type S Starts at $54,600, Heritage Edition $56,900

The 2027 Acura Integra Type S starts at $54,600 MSRP, ...
Depositphotos_309704250_S

What an Open Safety Recall Means (and How to Check Your Car Now)

The government recall check lists any safety recall on a ...
Car driving fast in the night city

Bay Area Bridge Tolls Rise Jan. 1 to $9 With FasTrak, $10 on Invoice

Tolls on the seven state-owned Bay Area bridges split by ...
Why does my car smell like burning oil?

How to Appeal an MOT Fail Within 14 Working Days (Before You Repair)

Email DVSA form VT17 within 14 working days of an ...

Trending on Motoring Chronicle

Inside the all-new 2027 Audi Q9 flagship full-size SUV cabin

Cadillac Recalls 14,540 Vistiq SUVs Over a Third Row Seat That Can Trap a Passenger

General Motors is recalling every 2026 and 2027 Cadillac Vistiq ...
Three sports cars parked in a row beside a large tree under clear blue sky.

Tennessee Coverage Failure Fee Jumps From $25 to $500 on July 1, 2027

Starting Jan. 1, 2027, anyone registering a vehicle in Tennessee ...
Black Chevrolet pickup plugged into charging station inside a modern garage.

GM Recalls New Silverado and Sierra EVs Over a Battery Fire Risk and Cracked Wheels

General Motors is recalling a small number of 2026 Chevrolet ...
BMW iX3 50 xDrive M Sport Pro in front three-quarter view

BMW Adds M340i and M440i Black Editions for Summer 2026 From £66,475

BMW is using its summer 2026 model-year update to give ...
TS Young Driver THINK Social 1200x628 D.jpg

Two Illegal Tyres Can Cost New Drivers Their Licence, TyreSafe Warns

New drivers have less room for error on tyres than ...