Why Hogging the Middle Lane Risks a £100 Police Fine and 3 Points

• Staying in the middle lane of a motorway with the left lane clear is treated as careless driving, the RAC warned in a statement The Sun published on 4 November.
• Police have held the power to hand out a £100 fixed penalty and 3 penalty points for careless driving from 16 August 2013, and those points stay on the driving record for 4 years.
• Highway Code Rule 264 sets the standard for every motorway driver: “Keep in the left lane unless overtaking.”

The Lazy Lane Habit That Police Can Fine on the Spot

A driver who sits in the middle lane of a motorway while the left lane runs empty can be fined £100 and given 3 penalty points. The RAC places middle-lane hogging under careless driving, and the Department for Transport named it in 2013 as one of the less serious careless driving offences that officers could now deal with by fixed penalty notice instead of a court summons.

The charge is careless driving under section 3 of the Road Traffic Act 1988: driving a mechanically propelled vehicle on a road without due care and attention, or without reasonable consideration for other persons using the road. Officers can issue the fixed penalty for the less serious cases, and the most serious cases still go to court, as the 2013 DfT release set out.

The RAC says the habit has not gone away. “Despite widespread publicity around the fines for careless driving since their introduction in 2013, middle-lane hoggers are still a common sight on UK motorways.” The RAC also says one in three motorists admit to continuously driving in the middle lane, and that only 50 per cent know it is illegal.

The AA’s 2023 survey of more than 13,000 drivers put middle lane hogging among the most frustrating motorway behaviours, with 21 per cent of participants in agreement.

What Rule 264 Asks of Every Motorway Driver

The lane rule is short. Rule 264 of the Highway Code reads: “Keep in the left lane unless overtaking.” A driver who is overtaking should return to the left lane when it is safe to do so, and the rule points to Rules 267 and 268 for how.

Rule 264 carries a second instruction. A driver in the left lane who comes up on emergency services, traffic officers, recovery workers or other people or vehicles stopped on the hard shoulder or in an emergency area should move into the adjacent lane, when it is safe, to create more space between the car and those people and vehicles. A move into the middle lane for that reason is what the rule asks for. Staying there for miles after the stopped vehicles are behind is the habit the RAC is warning about.

Rule 265 narrows the choice for some vehicles. On a motorway with three or more lanes, the right-hand lane must not be used, except in prescribed circumstances, by any vehicle drawing a trailer, by a goods vehicle laden above 3.5 tonnes and up to 7.5 tonnes that is required to be fitted with a speed limiter, by a goods vehicle laden above 7.5 tonnes, or by the passenger vehicles the rule lists. A car towing a caravan on a three-lane motorway has the middle lane as its furthest-right choice.

Rule 268 covers congestion. Where adjacent lanes are moving at similar speeds, traffic in left-hand lanes can move faster than traffic on the right, and a driver can keep up with the traffic in their own lane, including when that means passing vehicles in the lane to the right.

How £100 and 3 Points Reaches a Licence

The fixed penalty for careless driving came from a package announced on 5 June 2013 by Stephen Hammond, then Road Safety Minister. “Careless drivers are a menace and their negligence puts innocent people’s lives at risk. That is why we are making it easier for the police to tackle problem drivers by allowing them to immediately issue a fixed penalty notice rather than needing to take every offender to court. We are also increasing penalties for a range of driving offences to a level which reflects their seriousness and which will ensure that they are consistent with other similar penalty offences.”

The package set the careless driving penalty at £100 with 3 points on the licence. It also lifted the old £120 endorsable penalty to £200 for other offences, and left parking penalties as they were. The government said fixed penalty levels for most of these offences had stood unchanged from 2000.

Chief Constable Suzette Davenport, then the ACPO lead on roads policing, backed the change. “The new penalties are absolutely necessary to deal with drivers who are putting people’s lives at risk and police will not hesitate to enforce them. These measures should also act as a reminder to careless drivers that their behaviour will not be tolerated. The vast majority of drivers are law abiding, but some are still not getting the message. We said we would get tougher on those who make our roads dangerous and that is exactly what we have done.”

Edmund King, then AA President, welcomed the new powers and named middle lane hogging in the same breath as tailgating. “It is worrying that 3 quarters of drivers see others using mobile phones behind the wheel on some or most journeys1. This epidemic of hand held mobile phone use while driving has already cost lives and our members have demanded action. An increase in the standard motoring fixed penalty fine will help deter those who commit motoring offences including mobile phone use. AA members broadly support an increase in the level of the fixed penalty. Our members also fully support educational training as an alternative to penalty points. We are also pleased to see that at long last new powers and fines will be given to the police to tackle the top three pet hates of drivers – tailgaters, mobile phone abusers and middle lane hogs.”

The points come from the careless driving endorsement codes. CD10 covers driving without due care and attention, CD20 covers driving without reasonable consideration for other road users, and CD30 covers either. Each carries 3 to 9 penalty points, and codes CD10 to CD33 stay on a driving record for 4 years from the date of the offence. The fixed penalty carries 3 points, the bottom of that range. A separate guide sets out which points stay on your licence for 4 years and which last 11.

What Happened to the Fines After 2013

Fixed penalty notices for careless driving came into effect on 16 August 2013, and the DfT evaluation sets out the routes open to an offender. An officer can issue a warning. The driver can pay £100 and take 3 points. The driver can plead not guilty and go to the magistrates’ court. Or the police can offer a remedial driver training course instead of the fixed penalty.

The training route has conditions. The driver must not have attended the course in the previous three years, the driver pays for it, and the cost does not generally exceed the fixed penalty. The impact assessment put the average course at £90 against the £100 fine. A driver who fails the course, or is ineligible, receives the fine and points. A driver who does not pay, or who has taken the fixed penalty route within the previous year, goes to court.

Before August 2013 the choices were a warning, a summons or, in some cases, training. A court case for careless driving under the earlier system could bring a fine of up to £5,000, between 3 and 9 penalty points and, at the court’s discretion, disqualification. The 2013 power keeps that court route for the most serious cases and gives officers a faster option for the rest. Drivers can still appeal any decision in court.

The numbers show officers using it. From August 2013 to July 2015 a total of 5,194 fixed penalty notices were issued for careless driving offences in England and Wales, which works out at about 216 a month, or around 7 a day. That total covers careless driving of every kind, not middle-lane hogging alone, and the evaluation says July 2015, the last month of data, is likely to be an underestimate, so the true average is a little higher. In the 12 months after the change, driver licence endorsements for careless driving rose by 25 per cent year on year. By the second quarter of 2015, monthly training disposals typically outnumbered fixed penalty notices by around 3 to 1.

Officers knew the power existed. Of the road policing officers and staff surveyed, 92 per cent were aware of fixed penalty notices for careless driving, and 53 per cent said they were more likely to enforce the offence after the change. Only 9 per cent noted that the notices were not being implemented for these offences in their force area. The evaluation adds that other changes to policing procedures, such as Traffic Offence Reports, could also have played a part in the rise in endorsements.

Interviews in the evaluation give the view from each side of the notice. A police officer said: “The discretion we had has been diluted”. Another officer called the notice a “Little bit of a wake-up call, a refresher.” A legal advisor said: “A FPN wouldn’t improve road safety, an educational course would.” A male offender said: “The FPN is better than the stress of going court – it should cut down on your costs as well.” Another said: “I’m more aware of speeding traps by the police.” One more said: “It won’t happen again – I’m more cautious now.” On the chance of a repeat, a male offender said: “… You never know what circumstances are going to come up.”

What to Do When the Left Lane Is Clear

The fix is the plainest instruction in the Highway Code: move left. A driver who has finished overtaking should check the mirrors, signal and return to the left lane as soon as it is safe, which leaves the middle lane free for the next driver who needs it.

The RAC adds two cautions for the driver stuck behind a hogger. “While annoying, you should resist the urge to react because being overcome with road rage is more dangerous than lane hogging.” And on the other side of the lane, “Avoid undertaking as it is an offence in itself: try to move to the outer lane when safe to overtake.” Rule 268 gives the same direction: do not overtake on the left or move to a lane on the left to overtake. The court side of the undertaking offence is covered in this guide to middle-lane hogging.

A driver handed a notice has the choices the DfT evaluation lists: pay £100 and take 3 points for 4 years, ask about a training course where the force offers one, or contest the case at the magistrates’ court. The 2013 package kept court for the worst cases, where offenders can face higher penalties, and the careless drivers who reach a magistrate face a separate set of sentencing rules.

Sources

• Department for Transport: Evaluation of fixed penalty notices for careless driving
• GOV.UK: New penalties to tackle tailgating and middle lane hogging
• GOV.UK: The Highway Code, Motorways (253 to 273)
• The Sun: Middle lane hogger? Why your ‘lazy’ driving habit is actually ILLEGAL and could see you fined £100, warns RAC

Want more car content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for the best automotive news and analysis on the internet.

If you enjoyed this article, be sure to follow us on Microsoft Start.