Car Insurance for Drivers With Poor Credit Rose 37.7% to $3,944 in 3 Years

Car keys in a lock
Car keys in a lock (image courtesy Deposit Photos)
Car keys in a lock
Car keys in a lock (image courtesy Deposit Photos)
  • Drivers with poor credit and a clean record pay a median $3,944 a year for full coverage, up $1,081 or 37.7% from January 2023, NerdWallet’s 2026 Auto Insurance Rates Report found.
  • That rise beat the 35.9% increase for a good-credit driver with a DUI, who still pays more in dollars at $4,474.
  • Most insurers have stopped asking for increases, yet nonstandard insurers that cover poor credit and violations still file for rises, the steepest of them asking a median 5.2% more.

Why a Clean Driving Record Does Not Hold Your Premium Down

A driver with no tickets, no crashes and poor credit paid a median $2,864 a year for full-coverage car insurance in January 2023. By January 2026 the same driver paid $3,944. That is $1,081 more, a rise of 37.7%, steeper than for any good-credit profile in the report, including the one with a DUI.

A driver with the same clean record and good credit saw a rise of $576 over the three years. The gap between the two now stands at $1,585 a year, so poor credit adds 67% to the bill of a driver who files no claims. Spread across twelve months, $3,944 comes to about $329 a month, up from about $239 in 2023.

Credit explains why a flawless record does not protect the premium. Outside California, Hawaii and Massachusetts, insurers can price policies on a credit-based insurance score, and a low score pushes the price up even for a driver with a clean record. Three steps bring the bill down: comparing quotes from several insurers, raising the deductible, and keeping small claims away from the insurer. The sections below show the numbers behind each one.

What the Numbers Show by Driver Profile

The report tracked median annual rates for full-coverage policies across eight driver profiles from January 2023 to January 2026. A good-credit driver with a clean record pays a median $2,359 a year, up 32.3%. Add an at-fault crash that caused $10,000 in property damage and the price is $3,503, up 32.6%. A ticket for going 16 mph above the limit puts it at $3,043, up 34.6%. A DUI brings it to $4,474, up 35.9%.

The poor-credit driver with a clean record beats all four in percentage terms at 37.7%. In dollars that driver pays $3,944, which is $530 less than the good-credit driver with a DUI, $441 more than the good-credit driver with an at-fault crash and $901 more than the good-credit driver with a speeding ticket.

Add an incident to poor credit and the numbers climb again. Poor credit and a DUI costs a median $7,013 a year, up 40.4%, the biggest rise of any profile. Poor credit and a speeding ticket costs $4,815, up 38.2%. Poor credit and an at-fault crash costs $5,584, up 36.7%.

These are modeled rate estimates from Quadrant Information Services, not records of what drivers paid. They cover a 3-year-old Toyota Camry LE, a 35-year-old single driver and a policy with $1,000 deductibles on collision and on the other-than-collision cover for theft, vandalism and flooding. New business and renewal quotes are both in the mix, and Liberty Mutual is not included. Location, age and driving history shift a driver’s own price, so the medians show direction and scale.

Why Insurers Price Credit and the Three States That Ban It

A credit-based insurance score draws on a credit file like the score a lender uses, but insurers run it through a different formula. California, Hawaii and Massachusetts bar insurers from rating on credit at all. Everywhere else, insurers say the score tells them how likely a driver is to file a claim.

“It helps in predicting expected claims activity and loss costs more accurately,” Norman Niami, who sits on the Automobile Insurance Committee of the American Academy of Actuaries, wrote in an email.

In July 2007 the Federal Trade Commission told Congress that credit-based scores predicted risk well with income, race and ethnicity held equal. A 2016 study in the North American Actuarial Journal put average losses per policy 64.6% higher for the lowest credit scores than for the best, and its authors tied risk-taking behavior to both credit scores and claims.

Critics argue the practice hits low-income and minority drivers hardest. Michael DeLong, a research and advocacy associate at the Washington, D.C.-based Consumer Federation of America, says many drivers do not know their credit scores affect their car insurance rates.

“Credit scores are one of the most harmful things that results in you paying higher auto insurance premiums,” said DeLong. “The penalties are extremely severe.”

Raising a score takes time, and the payoff varies. Every insurer draws its own cutoffs, so a score one company treats as poor can count as fair at another. Niami says building credit “can produce a noticeable premium decrease in some cases, while producing little or no change in others,” depending on whether the new score moves a driver into a better rating tier.

DeLong adds that the standard advice is hard to follow for many households.

“Most people probably have some idea that you can improve your credit score by trying to pay your bills regularly and reliably, and using different kinds of financial resources and credit cards,” DeLong says.

“But again, that’s easier said than done,” he says. “If you’re struggling at a low-wage job and trying to juggle bills, or if you don’t easily have access to a credit card, that advice may not be especially helpful.”

Where Rates Rose Most and How They Compare With Income

The report’s baseline driver, with good credit and a clean record, paid a median $1,784 a year in January 2023 and $2,359 in January 2026, a rise of 32.3%. The BEA income data the report uses show income per person rising 13% over the same stretch, from $68,832 in the first quarter of 2023 to $77,816 in the first quarter of 2026, a gain of $8,984. The BEA counts as personal income “income received by, or on behalf of, all persons from all sources: from participation as laborers in production, from owning a home or business, from the ownership of financial assets, and from government and business in the form of transfers.”

Set the rate rises against that $8,984 gain and the burden differs by profile. A good driver gave up 6.4% of it, the $576 rise. A poor-credit driver gave up 12%, the $1,081 rise. A driver with a DUI gave up 13.2%, a driver with an at-fault accident 9.6% and a driver with a speeding ticket 8.7%. In Georgia, poor-credit drivers gave up 25% of that state’s typical income gain.

The state figures below are the report’s state medians, not figures for poor-credit drivers. Minnesota led the country with a 56.9% rise, followed by Iowa at 53.4%, Wisconsin at 52.8%, Nebraska at 52.6% and Illinois at 52.4%. Kansas also made the top ten, and the six Midwestern states averaged a 52.9% rise. Alaska had the smallest increase at 0.8%, then Oklahoma at 1.9%. Income outgrew premiums in only nine states, among them Alaska, Florida, Hawaii and Louisiana. For current averages in your own state, see how car insurance rates compare by state.

The report names three causes. Repairs cost more: parts and electronic components have climbed in price from March 2021, and crash-avoidance sensors and cameras need a specialized technician to replace, a climb the monthly figures for car repair prices track.

Each claim also costs more to settle. Insurance Information Institute and Casualty Actuarial Society figures put the growth in personal auto liability claim severity at 10.9% a year between 2019 and 2024. Lawsuits cost more as well: insurers point to social inflation, meaning claim costs that rise faster than prices generally. From January 2020 to January 2026, motor vehicle insurance climbed 56.2% in the Consumer Price Index against 26.0% for the whole basket, a gap that monthly car insurance price data follows.

What the Filings Say About 2027

The climb is flattening. Annual rises were 13.8% and 13.2% in the first two years, then 2.6% in the latest. Insurers file requested rate changes with state regulators, and the filings give a forward look at renewals, though a filing is a request and often takes months to reach a policy.

Insurers sought increases on 91.4% of customer policies in 2023 and on 67.5% in 2024. The share fell to 28.7% in 2025 and 24.2% through mid-August 2026. From January 2025 to mid-August 2026 the median filed change was 0%. Premiums have caught up with losses: the Insurance Information Institute said in a November 2025 review that auto premiums were “only just beginning to rebound from pandemic-era lows, lagging the rise in losses”.

Large insurers show the split. From January through mid-August 2026, State Farm filed for increases on 5% of its policies with a median filed change of 0%. GEICO and Auto-Owners each sought increases on 45% of their policies, yet their median filed changes were -1.2% and -0.6%, a sign that most of their customers are likely to see a cut at renewal.

Poor-credit drivers sit outside much of that relief. Nonstandard insurers that focus on poor credit or a history of violations still seek increases on most of their policies, the highest median filed change reaching +5.2%. Those drivers already pay more, and some face more rises heading into 2027. A survey in the report found 49% of insured Americans are stressed about the cost, and only 22% compared policies over the past year.

How to Cut the Bill

Compare quotes first. Every insurer builds its own pricing formula, and some forgive poor credit more than others. A review of October 2026 rates found that in 49.3% of ZIP codes in states that permit credit scoring, a different company offered the cheapest price to a poor-credit driver than to a good-credit driver. Prices change regularly, so shop again before each renewal. DeLong recommends quotes from several insurers, as some penalize poor credit less than others.

Raise the deductible next. Moving from a $500 to a $1,000 deductible trims the premium 12.8% on average. For a hypothetical driver paying $3,944 on a $500 deductible, that is $505 a year, leaving $3,439. The report’s $3,944 benchmark already assumes $1,000 deductibles, so check what you carry now. The trade is $500 more out of pocket on every claim, and a claim smaller than the deductible pays nothing, so keep the higher amount in savings.

Skip small claims. Bradley Flowers, founder of Portal Insurance in Mobile, Alabama, recommends thinking twice about minor claims, a cracked windshield for example.

“When you’re in one of these situations, let’s save our insurance for the really bad stuff,” Flowers suggests.

Keep the billing clean. Signing up for automatic payments and never missing a monthly payment earns a small discount and improves a driver’s risk profile with the insurer. Flowers also says patience pays for credit: “there’s a bunch of small things you can do that over a two- to three-year span make you look a lot better” to insurers.

Finally, match the coverage to the car. A driver who could afford to replace the car alone can drop collision coverage and the other-than-collision cover, and keep liability, which pays for damage a driver causes to others. A driver who could not replace the car might drop only collision, usually the costlier of the two, and keep protection against theft, vandalism and flooding.

Pull your current declarations page, note your deductible and coverage lines, and request quotes before your next renewal date.

Want more car content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for the best automotive news and analysis on the internet.

If you enjoyed this article, be sure to follow us on Microsoft Start.

Sources

Reviewed by Preetam Gadekar

Jarrod Partridge

Jarrod Partridge is the founder of Motoring Chronicle and an FIA accredited journalist with over 30 years of experience following motorsport and the global automotive industry. A member of the AIPS International Sports Press Association, Jarrod has covered Formula 1 races and automotive events at venues around the world, bringing first-hand insight to every race report, car review, and industry analysis he writes. His work spans the full breadth of motoring — from the latest EV launches and road car reviews to the cutting edge of motorsport competition.

Leave a Comment

More in News

GEM Motoring Assist warning about red light runners at UK junctions

Suffolk County Drivers Can Claim Up to $36 Back on Red-Light Fees by Dec. 8

Drivers who paid the $30 administrative fee on a Suffolk ...
An automatic number plate recognition camera and a decoy surveillance camera on a pole

Hempstead Drivers Can Sue Together for Refunds of $250 Bus Camera Tickets

A Nassau County judge ruled Nov. 10 that three groups ...
Yellow Acura Integra Type S driving beside a yellow first-generation Integra on a hill road

2027 Acura Integra Type S Starts at $54,600, Heritage Edition $56,900

The 2027 Acura Integra Type S starts at $54,600 MSRP, ...
Depositphotos_309704250_S

What an Open Safety Recall Means (and How to Check Your Car Now)

The government recall check lists any safety recall on a ...
Car driving fast in the night city

Bay Area Bridge Tolls Rise Jan. 1 to $9 With FasTrak, $10 on Invoice

Tolls on the seven state-owned Bay Area bridges split by ...

Trending on Motoring Chronicle

Businesses invited to take part in trial of the next-generation vehicle to grid EV charging

Every New Covered Car Park Could Need EV Chargers as DfT Reviews £3,600 Cap

The Department for Transport (DfT) and the Ministry of Housing, ...
Cam belt

What Happens If You Never Change Your Cam Belt? The Engine Decides, Not You

The belt fails, and on most modern engines, the failure ...
Premium black and red car rear seats with seat belts.

DOJ Sues Lyft for $53 Million, Alleging Rides Denied to Disabled Riders

The Justice Department sued Lyft on November 9 under Title ...
Learner Hatchback on a Wet Street

DVSA’s New Waiting Time Measure Shows 9.7 Weeks, Not the 21.8 Learners Were Told

The DVSA has scrapped its old headline waiting time measure ...