How a Fault Claim Cuts Your No Claims Discount (and What Protects It)

• A fault claim normally cuts an unprotected no claims discount by two years, so four years of discount become two.
• Windscreen-only claims usually leave the discount alone but must still be declared when you take out another policy.
• Protection usually keeps the years on your record, but the price is not protected, so a renewal quote can still rise.

The Label on Your Claim Decides Whether You Lose Two Years of Discount

The way your insurer records an incident sets what happens to your no claims discount. A fault claim normally cuts an unprotected discount by two years, so a driver holding four years drops to two. The Financial Ombudsman Service, which settles complaints about insurers, adds that every insurer should explain in its policy how it applies the cut.

A fault claim can land on a driver who did nothing wrong. The Ombudsman defines it as any accident where the insurer could not recover its costs from another party. That covers a crash the driver caused and an accident where nobody can be made to pay, such as a parked car hit by a driver who is never found. The AA adds two more cases that can cost a discount even when the driver is blameless: being hit by an uninsured driver and having the car stolen.

Some incidents leave the discount standing. Two insurers, Ticker and Marshmallow, both say a windscreen-only claim does not touch the discount, though the claim must still be declared when you take out another policy. Policies differ, so check your wording. For the repair bill itself, see the latest figures on windscreen repair costs. A second route is reporting an incident and paying the other person yourself. The Ombudsman says the insurer should log that as notification only, with no reduction. A driver who reverses into their own garage wall and pays the repair gets the same result: the insurer paid nothing, so the discount stays.

Reporting still carries a cost. The report normally stays on the insurer’s record and goes onto the shared industry database. Premiums can climb at the next renewal, the Ombudsman explains, as even a minor incident marks a driver as statistically likelier to claim later. Some insurers tell policyholders to report every incident, and silence risks a cancelled policy or a refused claim later.

Before you claim, ring the insurer and ask three things in this order. Will it be recorded as a fault claim? Can the money come back from another driver’s insurer? What does my policy do to the discount if it cannot? The answers settle a decision worth years of cheaper premiums.

What Lost Years Cost at Renewal

No fixed scale exists for the discount. The Ombudsman states that the amount is not set and varies between insurers, and Ticker says the figure for each year sits in the policy wording. The AA puts the saving at around 60 to 80 percent for five or more years and cites the Association of British Insurers for a saving of up to 30 percent from a single year. Most insurers stop counting at nine years, Ticker says. The Ombudsman gives the example of a driver with 15 clean years whose insurer caps at nine: the document shows nine.

Run the arithmetic on a hypothetical policy that would cost £1,000 ($1,340) with no discount. A 60 percent discount brings it to £400 ($536) and an 80 percent discount to £200 ($268). A 30 percent discount leaves £700 ($938), which is £300 ($402) more than the 60 percent price. The percentage moves the price by hundreds of pounds, and the scale in your policy documents decides where two years and four years sit, so ask your insurer for it.

The loss does not end at renewal. A policyholder earns one year of discount for each year without a claim, the Ombudsman states, and the extra year is added only if the policy year was claim-free. A driver who drops from four years to two needs two clean years to climb back, and a not-at-fault claim in the year also stalls the climb, as no year is added.

Moving insurer and then claiming can bite harder. The Ombudsman explains that some insurers step the discount back by a set number of years when a claim lands. Its example: nine years, a new insurer that caps at four, then a claim, and a step back to two years, so the policy shows two. Most insurers step back from five years, however many a driver holds, and in most cases that leaves three. The Ombudsman normally treats that as fair when the insurer made it clear at sale. A driver can ask for a letter setting out the starting discount, the insurer’s maximum and how the claim changed it, and the Ombudsman usually finds that request reasonable.

When a Not-at-Fault Claim Leaves the Discount Alone

A crash that is plainly the other driver’s doing can leave the discount untouched. The AA explains that the insurer can try to recover all its costs from the other driver’s insurer, and that recovery saves the discount. Until it does, the Ombudsman says, a claim for damage to your car affects the discount.

Timing helps. The Ombudsman states that the discount is only relevant at the annual renewal. If the insurer has found you were not at fault by the renewal date, the discount is untouched whether or not the claim file is closed. A driver who reports a non-fault accident and chooses not to claim stays clear too, unless the other driver makes a claim, and then the discount is affected until liability is sorted.

The weak point is a settlement made without you. Most policies let the insurer accept liability, the Ombudsman says, and it often finds the insurer has not explained that to the customer. An insurer that accepts liability might only have judged that paying beat fighting a claim it could lose in court. If the settlement goes down as a fault claim, the discount takes the hit.

You can fight it. Complain to the insurer first. If no final response arrives within eight weeks, or the answer disappoints, take the case to the Ombudsman, whose service is free. It checks the insurer’s decision was fair against the evidence the insurer held at the time, such as witness statements, engineers’ reports and CCTV. When it finds the settlement unreasonable, it is likely to tell the insurer to change the record to a non-fault claim and refund any extra premium. The full process is covered in a guide on how to win a motor insurance complaint.

What Protection Buys and What It Leaves Out

Many insurers sell protection for a small fee, the AA says. A protected discount means a claim for something like storm damage, theft or an uninsured driver does not cost you the years, and some insurers also cover fault claims, so the years survive even when the cost cannot be recovered.

Insurers write their own terms. Ticker asks for at least four years of discount and lets a protected driver make two claims in a year before the discount drops. Marshmallow asks for one year, covers one or two fault claims in a year, and a driver with three or more still loses the discount. Read the fee and the cover list before paying.

The catch sits in the price. In a lot of policies, protection keeps the number of years unchanged after a fault claim, the Ombudsman says, but the price is not protected. The AA explains the mechanism: the premium is built from your claims history, and the discount is taken off the final price. The claim stays in the calculation, so a driver with a full certificate can still face a higher quote at renewal, and when market quotes are rising the bill can climb further.

The Ombudsman sees complaints from drivers with a protected discount and higher premiums. It checks whether the insurer applied its terms fairly and, if not, will probably tell the insurer to refund the extra money.

Where Drivers Lose Years When They Switch or Share

Leave early and you lose the year. The Ombudsman says the discount is always a whole number: cancel 11 months into a 12-month policy and you leave with the years you arrived with, provided you had no fault claim. Ticker emails proof when its policy ends, and its customers can use the renewal invitation or renewal decline document as proof before then. Changing car part-way through the year does not affect the discount, Ticker says.

Check the new insurer’s maximum, as drivers lose years to a lower cap. A driver with nine years heading to an insurer that accepts four should still receive proof of all nine at the end of the policy year, the Ombudsman says, unless the insurer always made clear it would not.

Mind the clock. Most insurers accept a discount less than two years old, the Ombudsman says, and others accept one under three years old, sometimes only from the last insurer they had. Ticker keeps a discount valid for two years after a policy ends, then the driver starts from zero.

Some years never count. The AA and Ticker both say a named driver usually cannot earn a discount, and the Ombudsman hears from drivers who built one as a named driver and found they could not move it to their own policy. One discount works on one vehicle at a time, the Ombudsman says, and Ticker says each policy builds its own, so a second car starts from scratch. The Ombudsman expects the first car’s premium to rise only if the discount moves across. It has also heard from drivers who found their insurer would not accept a commercial discount on a private car or one earned abroad, and Ticker says most insurers refuse discount earned on another kind of vehicle, such as a motorbike.

Proof must pass a test. Ticker accepts an official company-issued document that names the policyholder, shows the previous dates of cover, states the entitlement, was earned under UK cover within the last two years and carries the vehicle registration. If no certificate arrives, the AA says to ask the insurer for one.

The Ombudsman also sets out how open claims work. A driver can cancel and move whenever they like with a claim still running. A claim settled for the driver reduces the discount only until the settlement. A claim that ends with the driver at fault means the insurer should release proof with the lost discount taken off. The Ombudsman does not think it fair for an insurer to withhold a discount you have earned, though it might not step in if you owe the insurer money.

Why Buying Proof of a Discount You Did Not Earn Is Fraud

Fake proof of discount is sold through social media, and Ticker calls using it fraud. A driver caught with a fake document will most likely see the insurance cancelled, must declare that on every future policy and pays much more for cover afterwards. Most insurers also keep the money already paid. A fault claim costs two years of discount, and the years can be rebuilt. A fraud finding can cost the policy and the premium, and it follows the driver onto every future application.

Check your policy first, as some insurers expect every incident reported. Then ask the insurer how it will log the incident, whether it can recover the cost and what your protection covers. Set the repair bill against the extra premium for each year of the climb back, and file only when the payout beats that cost.

Want more car content? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for the best automotive news and analysis on the internet.

If you enjoyed this article, be sure to follow us on Microsoft Start.